Menu of M57 Pizza in Montrose, Michigan, USA

Menu Overview

If you're in Montrose, MI, and craving a pizza experience that feels both authentic and crafted with care, M57 Pizza is a destination you shouldn’t miss. Nestled at 288 E State St, this takeaway spot brings a thoughtful twist to classic pizza offerings, delivering on flavor, variety, and quality ingredients.

Right off the bat, the dough stands out—thin yet flavorful, striking a balance many big chain pizzerias miss. The sauce is rich and vibrant, packed with herbs and freshly crushed tomatoes that give each slice depth without overpowering the toppings. Speaking of toppings, M57 Pizza truly knows how to pile them on. Whether it’s the chicken bacon ranch, a classic favorite, or the robust meatball sub that one customer raved as the best in years, the combinations feel generous and thoughtfully crafted.

The menu doesn’t stop at pizza. The Parmesan breadsticks come in a satisfying portion, perfectly crisp and cheesy, ideal as a shareable starter. Equally compelling are the wings, described as “perfectly done” with just the right balance of sauce—tangy, not overwhelming.

For a sweet finish, the stuffed cinnamon bread earns high praise; it’s indulgent and offers a delightful contrast to the savory pies. This cinnamon treat seems to cap off the meal in a way that lingers pleasantly in memory.

From a service perspective, the team at M57 is noted for warmth and attentiveness, making the occasional hiccups during their soft opening understandable rather than frustrating. Their online ordering system is functional but still improving; savvy customers recommend picking toppings carefully to avoid double charges on specials.

Size-wise, pizzas run slightly smaller than some expect, yet this doesn’t detract from the overall satisfaction. The pan crust option brings a thicker, buttery bite, ideal for those who want a heartier slice. The soft opening rush meant wait times could trail a bit, but the quality of food and the friendly atmosphere make each minute worthwhile.

Overall, M57 Pizza brilliantly caters to pizza lovers who crave quality, rich flavors, and the kind of care that’s evident from dough to delivery. Whether you’re ordering a classic pizza, diving into a stromboli, or enjoying the standout cinnamon bread, you get genuine flavor that feels made with love. Skip the predictable chains and give M57 a try—you might just find your new regular pizza haven in Montrose.